Competitor analysis · Marketing · Templates
How to do a competitor analysis, with a filled-in example
By T. Krause
A competitor analysis compares what your buyers would do instead of choosing you, including doing nothing. Here is how to find those alternatives, which evidence to trust, how to turn it into actions, and a filled-in example for an invented coworking space.
To do a competitor analysis, list the alternatives your buyers actually consider, including spreadsheets and doing nothing. For each one, write down its price, what it's strong and weak at, and where you win or lose against it, using notes from real lost deals as your main evidence. Then write a two-line summary and finish with actions that have names on them.
With your notes to hand, a small business can do this on one page in an afternoon. This guide covers how to pick the alternatives, how far to trust each kind of evidence and how to get from notes to a decision. The example further down compares an invented coworking space with two rivals, home working and cafés. If you'd rather start from a page with the headings in place, copy our free competitor analysis template.
Start with what buyers would do without you
The obvious starting point is a list of companies that sell something similar. A better one is the question April Dunford asks in her quickstart guide to positioning: "What would a customer do if your offering didn't exist?"
Sometimes the answer is a rival, and sometimes it's nothing at all. Dunford writes that doing nothing "could mean using a spreadsheet, using a manual process, or hiring an intern to do it". Those options cost money and effort too, so they count as competitors even though they have no sales team.
She also warns against "phantom competitors", companies that "theoretically could compete with you; you just never actually see them or lose to them in deals". A big name in your market may not be worth a section if your buyers never mention it.
To build your list, take your last ten or twenty lost deals and write down what each buyer did instead. If you don't keep a record, ask whoever talks to buyers. Keep the three to five alternatives that come up most. If a name appears once, keep it in the raw notes and watch for it next time.
How far to trust each kind of evidence
Evidence isn't equal. Your own conversations with buyers tell you why people chose. Everything else mostly tells you what's on offer.
| Source | What it tells you | What to watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Lost-deal notes | Why real buyers went elsewhere | People give polite reasons. Ask one follow-up question |
| Interviews with recent buyers | What they compared, and how | One person's memory. Count across several interviews |
| Competitors' pricing pages | Current prices and plan limits | Write the date you read them. Check whether a price is monthly or annual |
| Free trials or a visit | Setup time and what the first hour is like | One person's experience. Read the terms, since some restrict competitive use |
| Public reviews | Complaints that keep repeating | Unhappy and very happy people write the most, and old reviews go stale |
| Competitors' marketing pages | What they want to be known for | These are claims. Don't copy them into your notes as facts |
Write the source next to anything you might need to check later. Take an invented price: "€12 a month (pricing page, 5 October)" can be rechecked in a minute. "€12 a month" with no source will sit there being wrong a year later.
If you run interviews, our guide to user interview notes shows how to keep quotes separate from your reading of them. If your real question is how usable a rival product is, that's a narrower job called a competitive usability evaluation. The Nielsen Norman Group explains how it works: you compare your product against several competing designs.
Fill in the same four lines for each alternative
Use the same four lines for every section, so you can compare them at a glance. The sample wordings below are invented.
- Pricing. The price a buyer like yours would pay, with your own next to it for reference.
- Strong at. What they do better than you. If you can't write this line honestly, you don't know them well enough yet.
- Weak at. Something a buyer would actually notice. "Outdated interface" is an opinion. "Setup takes about 40 minutes before the first invoice" can be checked.
- Where we win or lose. Name the buyer and the situation. "We lose to people who already have payroll in it" tells sales when to walk away. "We have better value" doesn't.
Say how often each thing came up. "Three of four" tells a reader far more than "often", and it stops one memorable complaint from shaping your plans.
Write the summary and actions last
The summary goes at the top of the page, but write it once the sections are done. It takes two sentences at most: where you win and where you lose. Someone who reads only that should come away with a true picture, so each claim in it needs a line further down to back it up.
Then go through each "where we lose" line and decide whether you're going to do anything about it. Three answers are all fine: change the product or price, change how you talk about it, or accept the loss and stop chasing those buyers. Write down the first two as actions with a name on each. If you accept a loss for good, record that in your decision log so nobody has the same argument next quarter. A change in the message usually feeds a campaign brief.
A filled-in example: a coworking space
The coworking spaces, the people and every figure below are invented. The page belongs to the team of a 40-desk coworking space with a quiet room and two phone booths, open 08:00 to 20:00. It charges €220 a month for a desk or €20 for a day pass, and membership includes ten meeting room hours a month. It's laid out on the headings of the competitor analysis template.
Competitor analysis: desks in town
Based on the two rivals' price lists (read 28 September 2026), a day pass at Quillhouse, a tour of Millrace Desks and our notes from all 20 tours this quarter. Update every three months.
Summary
We win with people who take calls all day, because of our quiet room and phone booths. We lose on price and late opening to Quillhouse, on lockable rooms to Millrace Desks, and to home or a café when someone only needs a desk two days a week.
Quillhouse
- Pricing: €165 a month, €15 a day pass
- Strong at: price, open until 22:00, café on the ground floor
- Weak at: on our day pass we could hear calls across the open floor, and its one meeting room costs €25 an hour
- Where we lose: people who compare on price (3 of the 4 tours that chose it) and people who work evenings (2 of the 4, one of whom also named price)
- Where we win: people who take calls all day (4 of the 6 members who joined for the quiet had also visited Quillhouse)
Millrace Desks
- Pricing: €240 a month for a desk, €900 a month for a lockable room for four, no day pass
- Strong at: lockable team rooms, free car park
- Weak at: a 20-minute walk from the station, no way to try it for a day
- Where we lose: teams of three or more who want a door that locks (both tours that chose it)
Working from home and cafés
- Pricing: free at home, about €10 a day in coffee according to one tour
- Strong at: no commute and no monthly fee
- Weak at: nowhere quiet for calls in a café, nowhere to meet clients at home
- Where we lose: people who only need a desk two days a week (3 of these 5 tours). We have nothing between the €20 day pass and the €220 month.
What to do about it
- Lena: cost a two-day-a-week membership and bring it to the December meeting
- Marek: show the quiet room and phone booths first on every tour and on the home page
- Joris: find out what staying open until 22:00 on two evenings a week would cost
- Lena: decide by the end of January whether the back room can become a lockable team room
- Lena: add to the decision log that we won't match Quillhouse's price
Raw notes from tours (in a toggle on the page)
Of the 20 tours, 9 joined and 11 didn't.
Joined:
- 6 gave the quiet room and phone booths for calls as their main reason. 4 of those 6 had also visited Quillhouse.
- 3 gave the included meeting room hours as their main reason.
Didn't join:
- Chose Quillhouse. "It's €55 a month cheaper and I'm on my own all day."
- Chose Quillhouse. "Same desk, lower price."
- Chose Quillhouse. Named the price, and wants to work until about 22:00.
- Chose Quillhouse. "I work late. You close at 20:00."
- Chose Millrace Desks. Team of four. "We need a door that locks."
- Chose Millrace Desks. Team of three, wanted a lockable room. Also said the free parking helped.
- Stayed at home. "I only need a desk two days a week."
- Stayed at home. "Two days a week, so the monthly price makes no sense."
- Stayed at home. Only needs a room when clients visit, about once a month.
- Stayed in cafés. "I'm only in town two days a week."
- Stayed in cafés. "I spend about €10 a day on coffee anyway."
What to notice
Trace each claim back to the notes. The price loss to Quillhouse rests on tours 1, 2 and 3, and the late-opening loss on tours 3 and 4. The lockable room rests on tours 5 and 6, and the two-day week on tours 7, 8 and 10.
Of the eleven lost tours, Quillhouse took four and Millrace Desks two. The other five, the largest group, chose no competitor at all. A page listing only Quillhouse and Millrace Desks would have missed them, and the first action comes from that group.
The price loss to Quillhouse gets the third answer, accepting it. Matching €165 would take €55 a month off every desk to win back at most three tours a quarter, so the team leaves the price alone, and the last to-do puts that in the decision log.
Free parking is on the page as a strength but gets no action, because one tour in 20 mentioned it. Tour 9 gets no action either, and sits in the notes in case it comes up again.
These are small numbers. Twenty tours point to where to look, and they can't prove anything about the market, so three of the five actions are checks ("cost", "find out", "decide"). One only changes what visitors see first, and one writes down a price that's staying put. Next quarter's notes will show whether the pattern holds.
Do you need a SWOT or a feature table as well?
Usually not for a first version. A SWOT lists your own strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats, and the four lines above already cover the competitor side and tie it to real deals.
A feature table helps in one situation, when buyers really do compare a checklist, as they often do in formal software purchases. Keep it for that use, and only list features buyers have asked about. A table of everything mostly rewards whichever product has the most features.
How often to update it
Once a quarter suits most small businesses: reread the rivals' pricing pages, add the quarter's lost-deal notes and check whether last quarter's actions happened. Update sooner if a rival changes its price, or if a new name turns up in several lost deals in a row. Put the review in the calendar, because a competitor analysis goes out of date without anyone noticing.
To collect the raw material between reviews, keep one place for what you hear. Our customer feedback log gives each piece of feedback a row and a theme, so the quotes are ready when review day comes.
Competitor analysis in Prompt Notebook
Prompt Notebook is ours, so read this part with that in mind. The competitor analysis template is a single page. It has a callout saying what the evidence is, a Summary, one heading per competitor with the four lines, What to do about it as to-dos with a checkbox, and a toggle at the bottom for raw notes. The sample compares invented invoicing apps, so you can see a finished page before you replace it.
Paste quotes from lost deals into the toggle, and type @ to link any interview or call note pages they came from. Select the page and use Ask AI to draft the summary, then check each claim in the draft against the sections below, since it can sound more certain than your notes are. At the next quarterly review, page history shows what changed since last time.
Frequently asked questions
What should a competitor analysis include?
A list of the alternatives your buyers really consider, including doing nothing. For each one, the price, what it's strong and weak at, and where you win or lose against it. Then a two-line summary at the top and a short list of actions with names at the bottom. Say where your evidence came from and when you collected it.
How many competitors should you include?
Three to five is enough for most small businesses, counted from your own lost deals. Include home-made options such as spreadsheets if buyers really use them. Leave out companies your buyers never mention, however big they are.
Where can you find competitor information for free?
Pricing pages, free trials, public reviews, job adverts and what your own buyers tell you. Conversations with buyers are the most useful of those, and they cost only time. Write the date next to anything you copy from a website, because prices change.
How often should you update a competitor analysis?
Once a quarter works for most small businesses. Update it sooner when a rival changes its price or a new name shows up in several lost deals. Each review should also check whether the previous round of actions happened.
What is the difference between a competitor analysis and a SWOT analysis?
A SWOT lists your own strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. A competitor analysis looks at each alternative in turn and asks where you win and lose against it. If you have to choose, start with the competitor analysis, because it ties directly to real deals and to actions.