Prompt Notebook

Hiring · Interviews · Templates

Interview notes template: what to write down during a job interview

By T. Krause

Interview notes are the record a hiring decision rests on, so they need the candidate's words rather than adjectives. Here is a template with the questions written in before the candidate arrives, what to write under each one, and an invented interview with the notes it produced.

An interview notes template is one page per candidate per interview. It holds the questions you'll ask, in order, with space under each for what the candidate said. Write down their examples, numbers and the words they used, plus a line when they gave no example at all. Keep your own reactions in a separate section at the bottom. You write the notes during the interview and score the candidate afterwards, from the notes, on a separate scorecard.

Taking notes and scoring are separate steps, and the guide we quote below puts the rating after the candidate has left the room. Our interview scorecard guide covers the rating. This article covers the page you fill in while the candidate is still talking.

What interview notes are for

The clearest description we found is in the US Office of Personnel Management's Structured Interviews: A Practical Guide from 2008. It's written for federal agencies, but the note-taking advice works anywhere. It says notes should "summarize the content and delivery of respondents' answers", and should be of "sufficient quality and quantity to document the interviewer's reasoning for each rating on each competency".

The guide also says notes "should include actual behavioral examples", and that a rating should explain how an answer applies to the competency. So a note that reads "strong communicator" fails. Nobody can check it, and it doesn't say what the candidate said.

The template

Fill in everything above the first question before the candidate arrives:

Interview: [candidate], [role]
Round, length, interviewer, date
[ ] Told the candidate I'm taking notes

Q1. [first question, written out in full]
- What they said, in their words
- Follow-up I asked, and the answer

Q2. [second question]
- ...

Questions the candidate asked

Written after the interview
- My reactions (not evidence)
- Anything I didn't get to ask

The questions, written out. Every candidate for the role gets the same questions in the same order, so their answers can be compared. Writing them in advance also stops you from improvising a different question halfway through.

The checkbox. OPM's guide lists "inform the candidate that notes will be taken" among the things to do when the candidate arrives. It's easier to type with the candidate knowing why.

Reactions at the bottom. You will have a feeling about the candidate. Write it where it can't be mistaken for something they said.

How to write the notes during the interview

Write their words, not your verdict. "Found the duplicate by sorting by amount" is a note. "Methodical" is your conclusion, and it goes on the scorecard later, if the notes support it.

Keep the numbers. Amounts, team sizes, how long something took. Nobody remembers them the next day, and they let a reader check the story.

Note who did it. When a candidate says "we", ask what they did themselves, and write down the answer.

Write down the gaps. If you asked for an example and didn't get one, write "no example given". On a scorecard with "1: no evidence" as its lowest point, that line decides the score.

Leave the CV closed. OPM's guide says the interviewer shouldn't look at a candidate's résumé during the interview, because a strong one can make the same answer sound better. Read it before, then put it away.

Look up. The same guide asks interviewers to make "periodic eye contact" while taking notes. Shorthand helps. Tidy it up in the ten minutes after the interview, not during it.

A filled-in example

The firm, the role, the candidate and the interview below are invented. A 20-person accountancy is hiring a bookkeeper, and Sam runs the second-round interview, 45 minutes long, with three questions.

Interview: Priya Nair, bookkeeper
Round 2, 45 minutes, interviewer Sam
[x] Told her I'm taking notes

Q1. Tell me about the last time a month-end didn't reconcile.
- Current job: bookkeeping for a dental group, 3 practices
- Bank and ledger were 1,240 apart
- "First I check it's not timing": 2 card settlements
  cleared on the 1st, together 860
- Remaining 380: a supplier invoice entered twice.
  Found it by sorting the month by amount.
- Follow-up: how long? "About half a day."
- Follow-up: we or you? "I found it. I then set up a
  duplicate check we now run before every close."

Q2. Two clients need VAT figures on the same day and you
can only finish one. What do you do?
- Would ask both which deadline is the legal one
- Tell her manager before the day, not on it
- Follow-up: both legal? "Ask my manager which client.
  I wouldn't pick on my own."

Q3. Tell me about a client who kept sending records late.
- "I always chase politely and early."
- Asked for one specific client: talked about chasing
  in general again
- No example given

Questions she asked
- Which accounting software we use
- How many clients each bookkeeper looks after

Written after the interview
- Reaction: calm, easy to talk to. Not evidence.
- Didn't ask about payroll. Next round.

The numbers in Q1 add up, 860 plus 380 is 1,240, and that's part of what makes the answer checkable. Sam can tell from the page that the reconciliation story is a real event with a method, and that the duplicate check was her own idea.

Q3 is the line that matters most. In the room, Priya came across well, and the reactions section says so. The notes show that she gave no example of handling a late client, even after a second prompt. On a scorecard with "1: no evidence", client handling scores 1, whatever the conversation felt like. The debrief can then decide whether the next round should ask about it again.

Interview notes in Prompt Notebook

Prompt Notebook is ours, so weigh this section with that in mind.

Make the template once. Create a page with the outline above, using headings for the questions and a checklist item for the note-taking line. Then choose Save as template from the page menu. The page and anything under it are copied into Your templates in the Templates dialog, and later edits to the original don't change the template. Each new interview starts from the same questions.

Keep it private until the debrief. A page you create at the top of your sidebar is yours. Other people can open it only once you invite them, turn on its share link or publish it. A page created inside a shared page gets that page's access, so write your notes outside any page the other interviewers can open.

Score from it. After the interview, open the interview scorecard template and fill it in from your notes. It has a score and an evidence list for each competency, and the evidence lines can come straight from the page.

File it with the candidate. In the hiring pipeline template, each candidate is a row in a database with board, calendar and table views, and each row opens as a full page. After the debrief, type @ in the candidate's page and pick your notes page to link it there. Each candidate's record then leads to the notes behind the decision. People can open the linked page only if they have access to it.

Export when needed. If your HR system keeps the record, the page menu exports the page as Markdown or HTML.

Frequently asked questions

Should you take notes during a job interview?

Yes. OPM's guide calls regular, detailed notes "crucial" and says they "reduce the burden on the interviewer to remember details about multiple candidates". Tell the candidate at the start that you'll be taking notes.

What's the difference between interview notes and an interview scorecard?

The notes record what the candidate said, in order, during the interview. The scorecard rates the candidate on each criterion after the interview, with evidence taken from the notes. Our scorecard guide explains how to build the scale and run the debrief.

Should you type or handwrite interview notes?

Either works. Typing makes them easier to search and to link to the candidate's record. Handwriting can be quieter and easier to do while keeping eye contact. If you handwrite, type them up the same day, while you can still read your shorthand.

What shouldn't go in interview notes?

Anything that isn't an answer to a question about the job, such as what someone looks like or remarks about their personal life. Write each line as if the candidate might read it one day. Your reactions belong in the separate section, marked as reactions.

How is this different from user interview notes?

A user interview is research about a product, and you're listening for problems, not judging the person. The user interview notes guide covers that kind of note-taking.

Write yours before the next interview

Write the questions for your next interview into a page tonight, with the checkbox at the top and the reactions section at the bottom. Save it as a template, then open the interview scorecard template so the scoring page is ready when the candidate leaves.

Try it on your own notes

Prompt Notebook is free, with unlimited pages. Type one sentence and the AI drafts the first version.

Cookies and storage

Prompt Notebook needs one cookie to keep you signed in. Accepting turns on Google Analytics and Google's reCAPTCHA spam check on the contact form, and declining keeps the form working. Nothing optional runs until you choose.

Read the privacy notice